Planning Strategies for Accident Black Spots
Loading...
Date
Authors
Journal Title
Journal ISSN
Volume Title
Publisher
MANIT
Abstract
Road traffic accidents continue to pose a significant public health, economic, and urban
mobility challenge worldwide. In India, accident black spots—locations exhibiting a high
concentration of crashes and safety risks—contribute substantially to fatalities and serious
injuries. Despite the existence of national guidelines such as the Ministry of Road
Transport and Highways (MoRTH) protocols and IRC:131-2022, the integration of road
safety considerations into urban planning processes remains limited, particularly in
rapidly growing Tier-II cities. This study addresses this gap by developing planning
strategies for the assessment and mitigation of accident black spots through a spatial, risk
based, and planning-oriented approach.
The research was conducted in two phases. Phase I involved a comprehensive review of
national and international literature, policy documents, road safety guidelines, and black
spot management practices. The review examined conventional and emerging approaches
to
black spot identification, including crash-frequency methods, severity-based
approaches, GIS applications, road safety audits, and risk-based assessment techniques.
The analysis highlighted significant gaps in the integration of road safety management
within statutory planning frameworks and urban mobility planning processes.
Phase II focused on Bhopal, Madhya Pradesh, as a representative Tier-II city. The study
utilized officially identified accident black spots obtained from concerned government
authorities under a live project framework. GIS-based spatial analysis was undertaken to
map and examine the distribution of black spots across the urban road network. Detailed
field investigations and road safety audits were conducted to assess geometric
deficiencies, traffic movement characteristics, pedestrian exposure, visibility conditions,
roadside environment, and operational conflicts at each location.
A risk-based prioritization framework was developed to evaluate black spots using
parameters such as traffic exposure, pedestrian activity, geometric deficiencies, speed
related risks, and strategic importance within the city road network. Based on the
assessment, identified locations were classified into priority categories and analysed to
determine their dominant safety concerns. The findings indicate that high-speed vehicular
movement, inadequate pedestrian infrastructure, geometric deficiencies, visibility
constraints, and operational conflicts are the major contributors to unsafe conditions at
accident-prone locations in Bhopal.
Based on the diagnostic assessment, location-specific planning and engineering
interventions were proposed for priority black spots. The study further developed an
integrated framework for accident black spot management incorporating identification,
prioritization, road safety audits, intervention planning, implementation, and monitoring.
The proposed framework emphasizes the integration of road safety considerations into
urban planning instruments such as Comprehensive Mobility Plans, road safety action
plans, and city-level transportation planning processes.
The study demonstrates that accident black spot management should extend beyond
traditional engineering approaches and be incorporated into broader urban planning and
mobility strategies. The findings provide practical guidance for local authorities and
planning agencies and offer a replicable framework for improving road safety in Bhopal
and other Tier-II cities facing similar urban mobility and road safety challenge.